The Results Of A Photo Study Of A Probable King Rail At Brigantine
Dr. Bernie Master of Worthington, Ohio and
I
birded at E.B. Forsythe NWR (Brigantine)
on Thursday, August 19th.

While I was photographing the Clapper Rail above, on the salt side of the southbound dike,

a very brown colored Rail came out of the grass and crossed in front of the
first one. I
have seen and photographed
many Clapper Rails at Brig during the past five years
but I had never seen a bird as brown as the one above!

Two
Different Clapper Rails at Brig, June 2008 J
Of course, I sent the photos
in the table below to a bunch of folks with two
questions, 1) is this brown rail a Clapper or a King ? and 2) is
it a juvenile or an adult? To see a larger image of any of these photos, please click on either the thumbnails or the captions ...thanks!
The responses are as follows: 1.) From Scott Barnes, Senior Naturalist, New Jersey Audubon "
Hi Howard,
I am wondering if this bird is a very bright juvenile Clapper
Rail. Kings are generally denizens of freshwater marshes, and sometimes
low-saline brackish wetlands. By default I Some comments from NJ ex-pat Derek Lovitch follow: 'The
dark-centered wing coverts and scaps with nice wide fringes
certainly suggest KIRA. So does the very vivid dark-and-white flanks
and undersides behind the legs. I would like Scott" 2.) From Kevin Karlson, Wildlife Photographer and Co-author of "The Shorebird Guide" :
"
Howard,
I was out of town for a few days and just got this message. The bird is a juvenile
bird,
due to the condition of the underpart feathers and lack of definition on the flank 3.) From Frank Rohrbacher, Secretary of the Delaware Records Committee
"
Hi Howard,
I'm not a rail expert. Having said that I think that this is a juv King Rail molting
into adult. I am assuming that the area that the picture was taken in is suitable for 4.) From Nick Pulcinella, Secretary Pennsylvania Ornithological Records Committee :
"
Sorry, I didn't get back to you sooner but I've been working too many hours. The
rail looks like a young bird and I think it MIGHT be a King Rail. King is supposed
to have the 5.) From the Cornell Lab of Ornithology
"
Dear Howard,
Thanks for your inquiry. I sent your photos to two different ornithologists here at
the
Lab, just to be certain. Here’s the consensus:
It looks like a classic adult King Anne Hobbs, Public Information Specialist, Cornell Lab of Ornithology" 6.) And from Louisiana State University, Department of Biological Sciences " Hello Howard, I'm a PhD student studying hybridization between King and Clapper rails in Louisiana and a friend sent me a link to your page today. I have collected specimens and done genetic James M. Maley, PhD Candidate, Department of Biological Sciences, Museum of Natural Science, Louisiana State University "
Conclusion:
Based
on Dr. Bernie Master's experience, the comments above, and all I could find in the literature
on the identification |
||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Howard B. Eskin 2010
Please email your comments to hbeskin@voicenet.com
Please click here to go back to Bird Webpage
Index 